Finding the balance

I had the opportunity to speak to a group of secondary school DPs and APs at the ASDAPA mini conference in Auckland at the end of last week. They’d given me the title; “Finding the Balance, Science of Learning and Relational Pedagogy”. This is a question that can sometimes be framed as a choice (should teaching focus on the science of learning, or on relationships?) but in my presentation I chose to make the argument that we need both. [See my slides at the end of this post.]

I started with some simple definitions – the science of learning (SoL) helps us understand how people acquire knowledge, use memory, build on what they already know, and develop through practice and feedback. It asks…

  • How does the brain learn and remember?
  • How do what we already know, our attention and memory affect learning?
  • How do teaching, practice, feedback and recall support learning?
  • How can teachers make learning more effective?

Relational pedagogy (RL) helps us understand how trust, identity, belonging and a learner’s experiences shape their participation in learning. It asks…

  • How do trust, belonging and relationships affect a learner’s engagement?
  • How do a learner’s identity and experiences shape how they learn?
  • How can we help learners feel safe to ask questions, take risks and make mistakes?
  • How can teachers give learners more voice while keeping clear expectations?

These are different perspectives on teaching, but they are not competing approaches. Good teaching takes both seriously.

The first point I made was that the science(s) of learning is/are not a teaching method or a ready-made recipe. They draw on research from fields including cognitive psychology, educational psychology and neuroscience. That research can help teachers understand learning processes, but applying it in a classroom takes professional judgement.

The history of reading research offers a useful example. In 2000 the report from The National Reading Panel found benefits from explicit instruction in phonemic awareness and phonics. Those findings are important and were soon embraced by jurisdictions across the US and in included in legislation pertaining to how teachers should teach. But the panel also cautioned that phonics should not become a complete reading programme. Teaching the code is important; so is giving learners a broader, purposeful experience of reading.

In his 2003 research paper Tim Shannon summarises myths about the national reading panel report highlighting the problem with using the NRP document as an unyielding statutory rulebook, resulting in laws being passed that mandated a rigid “phonics-first-and-only” approach, overlooking the panel’s original, balanced recommendation to weave code instruction seamlessly into a holistic, comprehension-focused literacy environment.

The recent release of a 7-year audit of the NPD report by Denny Taylor highlights the problems that have emerged when the findings of the original report have been used to support just one particular perspective here, with Denny concluding that “…the NRP P/A and phonics meta-analyses have been used to gaslight the public.”

The point I am making here is that we need to understand how evidence can inform teaching without dictating every decision. We need to attend to what research tells us, what it does not tell us, and what we can see in front of us as learners respond.

The same care applies to relationships. Strong relationships do not replace subject knowledge, purposeful practice or effective instruction. Belonging on its own cannot resolve a mathematical misconception. But a learner’s willingness to reveal uncertainty can help a teacher discover what is going wrong and decide how best to respond.

To give this a practical perspective I used a simple classroom scenario. Imagine a student repeatedly making the same error when attempting a long division problem. The teacher has explained the process, modelled examples and tried again. Still, the student makes the same mistake.

It might be easy for both teacher and student to conclude that the student simply “can’t do it.” But the real issue may be that the learner is simply applying a rule that made sense in a different context, but not in the one being introduced now. Simply repeating the procedure won’t help if that underlying idea remains unseen.

In this situation understanding prior knowledge and mental models helps the teacher recognise why an error might persist. A trusting relationship makes it easier for the learner to explain their thinking without fear of embarrassment. Together, these perspectives point toward a more useful response with the teacher asking the student to show how they approached the problem, identify where their reasoning diverges, and choose an explanation or example that addresses that specific idea.

The relationship helps make the learner’s thinking visible. Pedagogical knowledge that draws on the sciences of learning helps the teacher decide what to do with it.

In another example I used I looked at what might happen when a student challenges a teacher’s explanation of something in class. A challenge might be poorly supported, or it might open up a worthwhile question. The teacher’s task is to distinguish between the two and guide the discussion with clear expectations.

Learning often involves comparing ideas, evaluating evidence and revising what we think. But discussion does not automatically lead to understanding. Learners need enough background knowledge, thoughtful guidance and a clear sense of how to reason well.

Relational pedagogy makes space for disagreement without turning it into a personal threat. The teacher might ask what evidence supports the student’s alternative, invite the class to consider it, and help them weigh the explanations. Sharing power with learners does not mean abandoning the teacher’s responsibility or expertise. It means using that expertise to help learners develop their own judgement.

Neither the brain nor a relationship operates in isolation from the world around it. What learners bring with them, the experiences they have, and the support they receive all shape what becomes possible.

This doesn’t mean that students must always feel comfortable before they can learn. Learning can involve uncertainty, effort and discomfort. The question is whether learners have enough support to persist, ask for help and recover from mistakes when the work is demanding.

That is one reason to move beyond a simple opposition between teacher-directed and learner-centred teaching. A teacher can explain a concept explicitly and then invite students to explore its implications. They can set clear learning intentions while offering choices about how to approach a problem. They can provide structured practice and ask learners to explain, question and apply what they understand.

The point is not to choose who leads every moment. It is to design learning that builds understanding, capability and increasing independence.

In the presentation, I described this as a continuous cycle:

  1. Know the learner: attend to their identity, experience, prior knowledge, strengths and challenges.
  2. Design the learning: decide what learners need to know, what should be taught explicitly, and how they will practise and apply it.
  3. Respond to the learner: listen, observe and assess; use what you learn to adjust the support or challenge.
  4. Develop agency and capability: help learners build the knowledge, confidence and judgement to take increasing responsibility for their learning.

Each part informs the next. Knowing the learner shapes the design of the learning. The learning gives us opportunities to see how the learner is thinking. Our responses help them develop capability, which in turn gives us a deeper understanding of what they can do and what support they need.

Relationships are not simply a means to academic achievement, either. Care, challenge, support, shared power and expanded possibilities can help learners experience both belonging and growth. Care does not mean we lower expectations. Similarly, high expectations need not imply control or emotional distance.

The science(s) of learning reminds us that learning is not magic. There are things we can understand about how knowledge develops, how memory works, and how teaching and practice can support learning.

Relational pedagogy reminds us that a learner is not simply a cognitive system to be optimised. Each learner is a person with a history, an identity, relationships, aspirations and a developing sense of what they are capable of becoming.

Think of this using a cooking metaphor. No single ingredient makes the meal, and simply using more of something isn’t necessarily better either. The recipe isn’t fixed. Our thinking needs to shift from “Which ingredient should we be using more of?” to “What is the right mix of ingredients to create the conditions for great learning?”

We don’t build relationships instead of teaching well. We build relationships as part of teaching well. And we teach well not only to help learners know more, but to help them become more capable and independent in how they use what they know.

That is why both SoL and RL need to be present in our teaching practices and in the way we design curriculum. The useful question is not which one matters more. It is: “how can the quality of our teaching and the quality of our relationships work together to help every learner thrive?”

By wenmothd

Derek is regarded as one of NZ education’s foremost Future Focused thinkers, and is regularly asked to consult with schools, policy makers and government agencies regarding the future directions of NZ educational policy and practice.

One reply on “Finding the balance”

Ata mārie Derek. Tau kē  –  Awesome. A great set of slides which demonstrate the balance in pedagogy for our tamariki. No one size fits all. Whatever the research demonstrates has to be moderated by the informed classroom teacher to met the needs of their ākonga in their context. Thank you for the concise presentation visuals.

Leave a Reply

What others say

The Learning Environments Australasia Executive Committee  has received a lot of positive feedback, which is greatly due to your wealth of knowledge and information you imparted on our large audience, your presentation has inspired a range of educators, architects and facility planners and for this we are grateful.

Daniel Smith Chair Learning Environments Australasia

Derek and Maurie complement each other well and have the same drive and passion for a future education system that is so worthwhile being part of. Their presentation and facilitation is at the same time friendly and personal while still incredibly professional. I am truly grateful to have had this experience alongside amazing passionate educators and am inspired to re visit all aspects of my leadership. I have a renewed passion for our work as educational leaders.

Karyn Gray Principal, Raphael House Rudolf Steiner

I was in desperate need of a programme like this. This gave me the opportunity to participate in a transformative journey of professional learning and wellbeing, where I rediscovered my passion, reignited my purpose, and reconnected with my vision for leading in education. Together, we got to nurture not just academic excellence, but also the holistic wellbeing of our school communities. Because when we thrive, so does the entire educational ecosystem.

Tara Quinney Principal, St Peter's College, Gore

Refresh, Reconnect, Refocus is the perfect title for this professional development. It does just that. A fantastic retreat, space to think, relax and start to reconnect. Derek and Maurie deliver a balance of knowledge and questioning that gives you time to think about your leadership and where to next. Both facilitators have the experience, understanding, connection and passion for education, this has inspired me to really look at the why for me!

Jan McDonald Principal, Birkdale North School

Engaged, passionate, well informed facilitators who seamlessly worked together to deliver and outstanding programme of thought provoking leadership learning.

Dyane Stokes Principal, Paparoa Street School

A useful and timely call to action. A great chance to slow down, reflect on what really drives you, and refocus on how to get there. Wonderful conversations, great connections, positive pathways forward.

Ursula Cunningham Principal, Amesbury School

RRR is a standout for quality professional learning for Principals. Having been an education PLD junkie for 40 years I have never before attended a programme that has challenged me as much because of its rigor, has satisfied me as much because of its depth or excited me as much because of realising my capacity to lead change. Derek and Maurie are truly inspiring pedagogical, authentic leadership experts who generously and expertly share their passion, wisdom and skills to help Principal's to focus on what is important in schools and be the best leader they can be.

Cindy Sullivan Principal, Kaipara College

Derek Wenmoth is brilliant. Derek connects powerful ideas forecasting the future of learning to re-imagine education and create resources for future-focused practices and policies to drive change. His work provides guidance and tools for shifting to new learning ecosystems through innovations with a focus on purpose, equity, learner agency, and lifelong learning. His work is comprehensive and brings together research and best practices to advance the future of teaching and learning.  His passion, commitment to innovation for equity and the range of practical, policy and strategic advice are exceptional.

Susan Patrick, CEO, Aurora Institute

I asked Derek to work with our teachers to reenergise our team back into our journey towards our vision after the two years of being in and out of 'Covid-ness'.  Teachers reported positively about the day with Derek, commenting on how affirmed they felt that our vision is future focused.  Teachers expressed excitement with their new learning towards the vision, and I've noticed a palpable energy since the day.  Derek also started preparing our thinking for hybrid learning, helping us all to feel a sense of creativity rather than uncertainty.  The leadership team is keen to see him return!

Kate Christie | Principal | Cashmere Ave School

Derek has supported, informed and inspired a core group of our teachers to be effective leads in our college for NPDL. Derek’s PLD is expertly targeted to our needs.

Marion Lumley | Deputy Principal |Ōtaki College

What a task we set Derek -  to facilitate a shared vision and strategy with our Board and the professional and admin teams (14 of us), during a Covid lockdown, using online technology. Derek’s expertise, skilled questioning, strategic facilitation and humour enabled us to work with creative energy for 6 hours using a range of well-timed online activities. He kept us focussed on creating and achieving a shared understanding of our future strategic plan.  Derek’s future focussed skills combined with an understanding of strategy and the education sector made our follow up conversations invaluable.  Furthermore, we will definitely look to engage Derek for future strategic planning work.

Sue Vaealiki, Chair of Stonefields Collaborative Trust 

Our Principal PLG has worked with Derek several times now, and will continue to do so. Derek is essentially a master facilitator/mentor...bringing the right level of challenge, new ideas & research to deepen your thinking, but it comes with the level of support needed to feel engaged, enriched and empowered after working with him.

Gareth Sinton, Principal, Douglas Park School

Derek is a highly knowledgeable and inspirational professional learning provider that has been guiding our staff in the development of New Pedagogies’ for Deep Learning. His ability to gauge where staff are at and use this to guide next steps has been critical in seeing staff buy into this processes and have a strong desire to build in their professional practice.

Andy Fraser, Principal, Otaki College